Antony HodariSolicitors
Case study · Leaks & Water Damage

Castle Point Borough Council agrees roof and gutter repairs and almost £2,000 damages in under three months

Written by Abigail Merchant · Fee Earner

SRA RegulatedNo. 569572
Est. 1984Over 40 years’ experience
4.8 / 5 3,700+ reviews on Reviews.io
96% Would RecommendReviewSolicitors verified
No Win, No FeeHousing disrepair claims

Our client, a Castle Point Borough Council tenant, had reported disrepair to the roof and guttering of their house, and to the kitchen and bathroom, for over a year.

The council inspected and carried out some work, but it did not resolve the problems and they returned.

Antony Hodari Solicitors sent a letter of claim the day after we were instructed, acting on a no win, no fee basis, and obtained an independent surveyor's report.

The claim settled in under three months from the letter of claim, without Court proceedings. The council adopted our surveyor's schedule of works, agreed to carry out the repairs within 120 days and to pay our client almost £2,000 in damages.

Case at a glance

Claim type: Housing disrepair claim
Main defect: Roof and guttering
Consequential disrepair: Kitchen and bathroom
Landlord: Castle Point Borough Council
Problems reported since: Over a year before instruction
Date instructed: July 2026
Letter of claim sent: July 2026
Expert evidence: Independent surveyor's report, August 2026; repairs estimated at around £4,200
Court proceedings: Not issued
Settled: September 2026, by Calderbank offer
Time from instruction to settlement: Approximately two and a half months
Handled by: Abigail Merchant
Outcome: Repair works on our surveyor's schedule within 120 days; almost £2,000 damages

What problems had our client reported?

Our client had reported disrepair to the roof and the external guttering, and to the kitchen and bathroom, which were the worst affected rooms.

They had been reporting these problems to the council for over a year. Our client is part of a family with young children, and living with the disrepair caused them stress and anxiety.

Why did the problem persist?

The council attended, but its visits did not resolve the issues.

Some inspections led to no work. Where the council did carry out work, it was partial, and the problems came back.

What did Antony Hodari Solicitors do?

We were instructed in July 2026 and sent a letter of claim the next day under the Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England).

An independent surveyor instructed by Antony Hodari Solicitors inspected in August 2026. The surveyor's report confirmed the disrepair and estimated repairs at around £4,200.

How did the claim settle?

The claim settled in September 2026 by a Calderbank offer, under three months from the letter of claim and without Court proceedings.

Castle Point Borough Council adopted the schedule of works prepared by our surveyor, agreed to carry out the repairs within 120 days and agreed to pay our client almost £2,000 in damages.

Is my council responsible for repairing the roof and gutters?

Under section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, a landlord of a short residential tenancy must keep the structure and exterior of the home in repair, which usually includes the roof and gutters. Liability depends on the tenancy, the defect, notice to the landlord, a reasonable time to repair and the landlord's response.

Our client had reported the roof and gutter problems to the council for over a year.

What if my landlord's repairs keep failing?

Partial or temporary repairs do not always meet a landlord's repairing obligation if the defect returns. Records of each report and each visit help show the history.

In this case the council's partial work did not last, and the problems returned.

How long does a housing disrepair claim take?

Many claims settle during the Pre-Action Protocol stage, within a few months of the letter of claim, while others need Court proceedings and take longer. The timetable depends on the evidence and the landlord's response.

Our client's claim settled in under three months from the letter of claim, without Court proceedings.

What is a Calderbank offer?

A Calderbank offer is a written settlement offer made without prejudice save as to costs. It can be shown to the Court when costs are decided, which encourages both sides to consider it seriously.

Our client's claim settled on a Calderbank offer.

Can I get compensation for disrepair from my council?

A tenant may be entitled to compensation for the period the landlord failed to repair after being told about the problem, as well as an order for repairs. Whether a claim succeeds and how much is awarded depends on the facts of each case.

Castle Point Borough Council agreed to pay our client almost £2,000 in damages as part of the settlement.

Related case studies

Has your council failed to fix your roof or gutters?

If you have reported repairs to your council or housing association and the work has not been done, or has not lasted, Antony Hodari Solicitors can assess whether you may have a housing disrepair claim.

We act on a no win, no fee basis in eligible housing disrepair cases, and you can read more of our case studies to see how similar matters have concluded.

Start your housing disrepair claim assessment Or call 0345 504 0005

Free case assessment

No obligation · No win, no fee · 24hr response

By submitting this form you agree to our privacy policy. We will only use your details to respond to your enquiry.

Prefer to speak to someone now?

0345 504 0005 Mon–Fri 9am–5:30pm · No obligation

“Every case matters. We never allow ourselves to become immune to the conditions our clients are living in.”

Emma Rees · Director