Antony HodariSolicitors
Evidence and surveys

Evidence guide: what to gather before you make a claim

Housing disrepair claims are won on evidence. This guide explains exactly what to collect, how to record it, and what happens if you have not kept everything. Written for tenants preparing to bring a claim.

SRA RegulatedNo. 569572
Est. 1984Over 40 years’ experience
4.8 / 5 3,700+ reviews on Reviews.io
96% Would RecommendReviewSolicitors verified
No Win, No FeeHousing disrepair claims
What evidence do I need for a housing disrepair claim?

The strongest claims have three things: proof the disrepair exists (photographs, video and an independent survey), proof you reported it to your landlord (letters, emails, texts or call records), and proof of the effect on you (damaged belongings, health records and your own account). You do not need all of it to start a claim, and we can help you gather what is missing.

Why evidence decides disrepair claims

A housing disrepair claim has to prove two things: that the disrepair exists and your landlord is responsible for it, and that your landlord knew about it and failed to act within a reasonable time. Almost every dispute in a disrepair case comes down to one of those two points. Landlords rarely argue that damp is pleasant to live with. They argue that it is not their responsibility, or that they were never told.

That is why your evidence matters from the very first report. The tenants who recover the most, and get repairs ordered fastest, are usually the ones who can show a clear paper trail: here is the problem, here is when I reported it, here is what happened next.

1. Photographs and video

Photograph everything, and keep photographing it. The most persuasive photo evidence shows the problem getting worse over time while the landlord does nothing.

  • Take wide shots and close-ups. A wide shot shows where the problem is in the room; a close-up shows how bad it is.
  • Repeat monthly. A single photo shows a defect. A series of photos taken over months shows neglect.
  • Video is powerful for some defects. Running water from a leak, a boiler failing to fire, vermin activity and condensation running down walls all show better in video.
  • Do not worry about timestamps. Modern phones embed the date and time in the photo file automatically. Keep the original files rather than screenshots, as screenshots strip that data out.

2. Your reports to the landlord

This is the single most important category of evidence, because notice is what makes a landlord legally liable. If you are at the start of the process and have not yet reported the problem, our reporting guide covers how to do it so it counts. Once you have reported, keep a copy of every contact:

  • Letters and emails, including the landlord's replies (or the absence of them)
  • Text and WhatsApp messages, which count as written reports
  • Webchat and app conversations, screenshotted at the time, as these are often deleted or expire
  • Repair reference numbers from your landlord's phone line, app or online portal
  • Notes of phone calls: the date, who you spoke to, and what was said

If you have reported problems by phone only, do not assume your claim is lost. Your landlord's own call logs and repair records can be obtained during the claim, and your own consistent account carries weight. But from today onwards, put reports in writing so there is no argument later.

Keep a log of every visit

Operatives, surveyors and housing officers may visit several times before anything is fixed. Every visit is evidence that your landlord knew about the problem, and a visit that produced nothing is evidence that they failed to act. Record, for each one:

  • The date and time they were booked to attend, and whether they turned up when they said they would
  • Who attended: their name, the company they were from, and their role if you can get it
  • How long they stayed and what they looked at
  • What they said: what they thought the cause was, what works were needed, and when the works would be done
  • Anything they did, such as taking damp readings, photographs, or carrying out a temporary fix

A notebook or a note on your phone is enough. Write it on the day, while it is fresh. Missed and late appointments matter too: note any time you took off work or waited in for someone who did not arrive, as this can form part of your compensation.

Confirm every visit in writing the same day

After each visit, send your landlord a short email or message setting out what happened: who came, when, what they told you, and what they said would happen next. If they told you nothing was wrong, say that too. A conversation on your doorstep is something nobody can prove. An email sent the same day is a written record your landlord has to answer, and if they do not correct it, it stands as the account of what was said.

Do the same after any phone call about repairs. Two or three lines are enough: the date, who you spoke to, and what you were told.

“The first question a landlord's solicitor asks is not whether the disrepair exists. It is when their client was told. Tenants who can answer that question with a message or a reference number are in a very strong position.”

Stephen Lund · Director

3. Documents and records

Gather the paperwork that establishes your tenancy and the history of the property:

  • Your tenancy agreement
  • Any letters from your landlord about repairs, inspections or works
  • Environmental health reports, if the council has inspected
  • Contractor job sheets or cards left after visits

Do not worry if you are missing documents. Under the Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims, your landlord must disclose their own repair records and relevant documents once a claim begins. Their records often prove the case for us.

4. Damaged belongings

Compensation can include the cost of belongings ruined by disrepair: mouldy clothes and bedding, water-damaged furniture, ruined carpets and electricals. To support this part of the claim:

  • Photograph damaged items before you throw them away
  • Keep receipts if you have them, or note roughly when and where items were bought and what they cost
  • Keep receipts for anything you have had to buy as a replacement, or spend because of the disrepair, such as higher heating bills or a dehumidifier

5. Health impact

If the disrepair has affected your health or your family's health, for example breathing problems linked to damp and mould, tell your GP and mention the housing conditions at the appointment so it is noted in your records. Keep prescriptions and appointment letters. With your consent, medical records can be obtained to support this part of the claim.

You do not need medical evidence to start a claim. But where health has been affected, especially a child's, it can significantly strengthen the case.

6. The independent survey

Once your claim is under way, an independent surveyor will inspect your home and prepare a report identifying the defects, their likely cause, and the works needed to put them right. This is expert evidence the court relies on, and it is arranged as part of the claim. You do not need to commission your own survey before contacting us.

Your job before the survey is simple: do not redecorate over the problem, and do not let anyone persuade you the disrepair is not worth reporting because it has been painted over before.

Your evidence checklist

Start today. Every item helps, and none of them is essential to begin a claim.

✓
Photograph every defect: wide shot plus close-up, repeated monthly
✓
Report problems in writing and keep copies of every message
✓
Note repair reference numbers and details of every phone call
✓
Log every visit: who came, when, whether they were on time, how long they stayed and what they said
✓
Email your landlord the same day to confirm what you were told at each visit or call
✓
Keep your tenancy agreement and any landlord letters together
✓
Photograph damaged belongings before disposing of them, and keep receipts
✓
Mention housing conditions to your GP if health has been affected

What if you have not kept everything?

Very few tenants come to us with a complete file, and you do not need one. Missing evidence can usually be rebuilt: landlords must disclose their repair records, phone logs can be requested, and the independent survey establishes the current condition of the property. The worst thing you can do is delay starting a claim because your records feel incomplete. Start gathering from today, and let us worry about the rest.

For what a successful claim can be worth, see our compensation guide.

Evidence questions, answered

I only ever reported the problems by phone. Can I still claim?

Yes. Written reports are the easiest to prove, but they are not the only way to establish notice. Your landlord's own call logs and repair records can be obtained during the claim, and your consistent account of when and how you reported the problem carries evidential weight. From now on, follow up phone reports with a short text or email so the position is beyond argument.

Do I really need to email my landlord after every visit?

It is the single cheapest thing you can do to strengthen a claim. Without it, what an operative or housing officer told you on the day is your word against theirs. A short email the same day, saying who came, what they said and what they promised, puts it in writing. If your landlord does not reply to correct it, that email becomes the record of the visit. It takes two minutes and it removes the most common argument landlords run.

Do my photos need timestamps to count as evidence?

Photos taken on a phone almost always carry the date and time automatically in the file's metadata, so you do not need a visible stamp on the image. Keep the original files rather than screenshots or re-saved copies, as those can strip the metadata out. If in doubt, back your photos up somewhere safe and leave them unedited.

I threw away my damaged belongings. Have I lost that part of the claim?

Not necessarily. If you have photos of the damaged items, that helps considerably. If not, a reasonable account of what was damaged, when it was bought and roughly what it cost can still support a claim for damaged belongings. Going forward, photograph anything else that gets damaged before you dispose of it.

Should I get my own survey done before contacting a solicitor?

No, and please do not pay for one. An independent expert survey is arranged as part of the claim itself, and it is carried out by a surveyor whose report is prepared for use in legal proceedings. A privately commissioned report is rarely in the right form and usually means paying twice for the same thing.

My landlord's contractor inspected but nothing happened. Does that help my claim?

Yes, considerably. An inspection proves your landlord knew about the problem, which is the key ingredient of liability. Note the date of the visit, who attended, and anything they said about the works needed. If they left a job sheet or card, keep it. A landlord who inspected and then failed to act is in a weaker position than one who claims they never knew.

How far back can my claim go?

Compensation is generally assessed over the period your landlord knew about the disrepair and failed to fix it, and claims are subject to legal time limits, typically six years for a claim brought in contract. The practical point: the longer you have lived with the problem, the more important your older evidence becomes, so do not delete old messages or photos. If you are worried about time limits, contact us and we will advise on your specific dates.

Not sure you have enough evidence?

You do not need a complete file to start. Tell us what you have and when you first reported the problem, and we will assess your case for free and help you gather the rest.

SRA Regulated · No. 569572 Est. 1984 · Over 40 years’ experience ★★★★★ 4.8 / 5 · 3,700+ reviews on Reviews.io 96% Would Recommend · ReviewSolicitors verified No Win, No Fee · Housing disrepair claims

Free case assessment

No obligation · No win, no fee · 24hr response

By submitting this form you agree to our privacy policy. We will only use your details to respond to your enquiry.

Prefer to speak to someone now?

0345 504 0005 Mon–Fri 9am–5:30pm · No obligation

“Every case matters. We never allow ourselves to become immune to the conditions our clients are living in.”

Emma Rees · Director